Recovery guide
Does edging count as a relapse on NoFap?
Not automatically. NoFap, the online community, says in its own FAQ that edging “counts” as masturbation, since masturbation without orgasm is still masturbation. It also says edging to porn “counts” as using porn. But the same FAQ adds that something counting against your goals does not, by itself, make it a relapse.
The International Society for Sexual Medicine, a medical society, describes edging as “a sexual practice that allows a person to delay orgasm.” Our page on what edging is explains the term in more depth.
Is it a relapse if you start and stop before orgasm?
Stopping before orgasm doesn’t change what the act counts as on NoFap. By the FAQ’s reasoning, starting to masturbate and then stopping is still masturbation, just as edging is. Whether it is also a relapse is a separate question, and the FAQ treats it separately. On that question, the FAQ says that “just because something ‘counts’ as not reaching your goals doesn’t mean that it meets” the criteria for a relapse. The word “criteria” here means the test for calling something a relapse.
The relapse criteria themselves, and when a streak counter resets, are covered in what counts as a relapse on NoFap. If some fluid leaked while edging, that is a separate question again, answered in whether precum breaks NoFap.
If you are thinking about ending your life, call your local emergency number or go to findahelpline.com.
Does edging count as finishing?
On its own, no, and on NoFap it doesn’t need to be finishing to count. NoFap’s FAQ still counts edging as masturbation whether or not it ends in orgasm, so finishing is not what decides it.
With porn involved there are two counts, masturbation and porn use. Without porn there is one.
Is edging allowed on NoFap?
Not if your goal rules out masturbation. By the FAQ’s count, edging falls within such a goal. Under a goal that rules out porn, edging to porn is in the same position.
For goals like these, stopping short of orgasm is not a way around the challenge.
The FAQ’s wording speaks of “your goals.” So the goal edging is counted against can differ from one person to the next.
What counts in a challenge is a rules question, not a health question about whether edging does any harm in itself. NoFap’s FAQ answers the rules question, as a community’s own ruling on its own challenge. What is and is not known on the health question is covered in whether edging is bad for you.
Does edging count as a loss in No Nut November?
For edging during No Nut November, one rule list documented by Know Your Meme, a meme encyclopedia, counts any intentional orgasm as a loss, even one without ejaculation. That rule is about orgasm, not about edging that stops short of it. The same list adds that “there is no three strikes rule,” so an intentional orgasm during edging is a loss the first time. The rule lists themselves are covered on our page on the No Nut November rules.
Sources
- What is edging and does it "count"? NoFap (By The NoFap® Team). Link
- What is “edging” and why might it be employed? International Society for Sexual Medicine (ISSM); author Rachel Baxter; reviewed by the medical professionals of the ISSM's Communication Committee. Link
- No Nut November. Know Your Meme. Link