Porn Addiction
Solution

Recovery guide

How do you masturbate without using pornography?

When you masturbate without using pornography, imagination and memory take the place of the screen, along with close attention to what the body is feeling. HuffPost’s guide to masturbating without porn says it “might take a little extra work.” Stephen Snyder, quoted in the same guide, says that without porn it is “not as immediately stimulating.” In practice, the guide’s advice is to build fantasies from your past sexual experiences and to aim at getting genuinely excited, not just at orgasm. If no fantasy comes to mind, attention to sensation is the other source, since it needs no story at all.

What do you focus on instead of porn?

On a picture in your mind, on the feeling of arousal in your body, or on both. The picture can be a fantasy you make up or a memory of something you have lived. The feeling is the physical side of arousal, noticed as it happens. A screen used to supply the picture from outside. Without one, the picture comes from you, or you leave pictures out and stay with the feeling.

These are two different kinds of attention, and they work in different ways. A fantasy builds a scene. Your mind supplies the people, the place and what happens, and the arousal comes from the story. Attention to sensation builds no scene at all. It stays with what the body is already feeling, as it changes from one moment to the next.

In a lab study, forty-one women each came in twice to watch erotic films, with a short recorded exercise each time (Velten et al., 2018). The study found that, compared within the same women, an exercise focused on the sensations of arousal was followed by greater felt arousal than a visualization exercise, but by lower genital arousal. Felt arousal is how turned on the women reported feeling. Genital arousal is the body’s physical response. Both were measured continuously while the films played. The sensation exercise was a mindfulness task, a recorded body scan focused on the sensations of genital arousal. The order of the films and exercises was varied.

Felt arousal and the body’s response also agreed more closely when attention was on sensation. The study found this closer agreement in one small group of women in a lab. Their arousal was measured while erotic films played, so the findings cannot show what happens without a screen, for men, at home, or for people trying to change their porn use. The study found these differences against a visualization exercise as the comparison task, and its published summary does not say what the women pictured in it, so the findings cannot be read as a test of fantasy against sensation.

What if porn is all you have ever used?

One starting point is material you already have. HuffPost’s guide, citing experts, says: “Use your past sexual experiences as material for your fantasies.” Snyder, quoted in the same guide, advises: “Cultivate arousal, not just orgasm.” The guide also suggests thinking “in terms of getting genuinely excited.”

The first line is about material. A memory is something you have actually lived, so it does not have to be invented from nothing. It comes with its own details: a place, a person, how it felt. For someone with few experiences to draw on, imagination does the same job.

The second line is about the aim. To cultivate something is to grow it with care. Snyder’s point is that arousal is worth building, rather than treating orgasm as the only goal. Getting genuinely excited puts attention on the feeling as it rises. That brings the two kinds of attention together: a scene or a memory to start from, and the feeling itself as it builds.

Why might porn still feel like the easier choice?

For someone who has always used it, porn is the familiar source of arousal and, by Snyder’s account, the more immediately stimulating one. Snyder, quoted by HuffPost, has an idea that goes further than habit. He suggests that when porn is where the arousal comes from, a partner’s presence can come to feel like a negative. In his account, that is because being with a partner means turning off the porn, and so turning off the arousal.

Whether that really happens is weighed in our comparison of masturbating with and without porn.

When the pull back to a screen is strong, ways of meeting that urge are covered in our guide to resisting the urge to masturbate.

Do you have to tell your partner what you think about when you masturbate?

Not according to sexologist Tanya Koens, who says in a piece for ABC News that fantasies “are personal and they belong to us.” She adds: “Our partners do not have a right to what goes on inside our head.”

Koens’s point is about privacy. On her reading, what happens in your own mind belongs to you, and you are under no obligation to reveal it to a partner. It is one sexologist’s view.

Thinking about a partner is imagination, not a screen, so it fits within what masturbating without porn means. For someone trying to stop using porn, whether masturbating without it counts as a slip is covered in our page on masturbation and relapse. Whether to masturbate at all while quitting porn is a separate question, taken up in our page on whether quitting porn means stopping masturbation.

References

  • Velten, J., Margraf, J., Chivers, M. L., & Brotto, L. A. (2018). Effects of a Mindfulness Task on Women’s Sexual Response. Journal of sex research. https://doi.org/10.1080/00224499.2017.1408768

Sources

  1. How To Masturbate Without Porn. HuffPost. Link
  2. Am I being unfaithful if I fantasise about other people? ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation); sexologist Tanya Koens. Link

A self-directed video course by Angus Munro, a clinical psychologist registered in Australia. Thirty-two video lessons, a one-page summary for each, and a plan you build for yourself.

Angus Munro wrote this page and sells the Porn Addiction Solution course. This page is general education; it can’t tell you what’s right for your situation.

Angus Munro

Clinical Psychologist, Sydney, Australia

Angus Munro is a clinical psychologist registered with AHPRA in Australia. He wrote the Porn Addiction Solution course.

Full profile and credentials