# Masturbation with vs without porn: what's the difference, and are there benefits?

> Masturbation without porn benefits, weighed: what is known about porn use and masturbation, what PMO and MO mean, and the conditioning claim.

**By Angus Munro, Clinical Psychologist (AHPRA Reg. PSY0001626434)**  
Published 18 November 2026 · Last reviewed 18 November 2026

---

The only difference is the porn, and neither of the two studies below found porn use linked with worse results overall: one took masturbation into account, the other measured women's sexual response during masturbation and partnered sex (Perry, 2020b; McNabney et al., 2020). Neither tested a switch from one to the other, so neither can say whether masturbation without porn brings benefits. [Our guide to masturbating without porn](/how-to-masturbate-without-porn/) covers what takes the place of a screen, such as fantasy or physical sensation, and how people go about it.

## Is masturbation itself the problem?

A narrative review of research on masturbation in adults concluded that it is a normal and widespread behavior linked with aspects of sexual health and well-being, while its impulsive-compulsive, unwanted or atypical forms have been linked with problems (Karageorgou & Agorastos, 2025a).

A narrative review is a written overview that gathers earlier studies and discusses them. Impulsive-compulsive means acting on sudden urges and repeating something despite wanting to stop. Unwanted means at odds with a person's own values and sense of who they are.

Masturbating, with porn or without it, does not by itself establish a disorder. Neither does how often someone does it, or a strong sex drive. Worrying about your own use, scoring high on a screening questionnaire and being diagnosed by a professional are three different things.

## Is MO as bad as PMO?

The two studies below did not find porn use linked with worse results overall, though they measured different outcomes, and in the study of relationship happiness this held once masturbation was taken into account (Perry, 2020b; McNabney et al., 2020). NoFap, an online community built around stopping porn, and often masturbation too, defines PMO in its glossary as porn, masturbation and orgasm. On this page, MO means the same without the porn.

Which is worse depends on what you mean by worse. Worse for a relationship, for sexual response, for time and for a sense of control are separate questions. The studies below reported results on relationships and sexual response, not on time or control. When porn is watched during masturbation, asking only about porn use may also pick up the masturbation.

A nationally representative survey uses a sample chosen to look like a whole country's population. In two such surveys, with samples of 1,977 and 10,106, masturbation went with lower relationship happiness for men and women, while porn use had no link with it, or lost its link, once masturbation was taken into account (Perry, 2020b). Taking masturbation into account means comparing people with similar masturbation habits, to see whether porn use added anything on its own. The researchers also reported that the evidence pointed to a slight positive link between porn use and relationship happiness, once masturbation and differences between men and women were accounted for.

These were one-time surveys, so they show a link, not which came first. They cannot tell whether masturbating more comes before less happiness in a relationship, or the other way round.

An opt-in sample is made up of people who chose to take part, so it does not mirror a whole population. In an opt-in community sample of 2,433 women from several countries, more frequent porn use went with less difficulty with arousal and orgasm, more pleasure and a higher share of masturbation ending in orgasm when the women masturbated, and was not linked with their relationship or sexual relationship satisfaction (McNabney et al., 2020). Again, this was a one-time survey. The women came from the general community, not from people seeking help with porn. The results say nothing either way about men.

## Are there benefits to masturbating without porn?

The two studies above reported no test of whether a switch to masturbating without porn brings a benefit, since they compared different people at one time, not the same people before and after a switch. Different people can differ in many ways besides porn, so a gap between them is hard to put down to porn alone. No study was found that compared the same people masturbating with porn and without it, or that assigned people to masturbate with porn or without it and compared the two.

Both studies report averages across many people, and an average cannot settle how porn fits into any one person's life. Someone can sit right on the average and still feel their use has gone further than they want.

So a reason to leave porn out of masturbation has to come from how the porn use sits with you, not from a shown benefit of leaving it out. It might be a clash with your values or an agreement with a partner. Reasons like those count in their own right. No study was found that compared keeping, pausing or stopping masturbation in people stopping porn. Our page about whether quitting porn means stopping masturbation takes that question further.

You may also have met a popular claim: that masturbating to porn trains arousal to respond to a screen. Neither study above reported a test of it, though the survey of women found that, during partnered sex, more frequent porn use went with less difficulty with arousal and a longer time to orgasm, and had no link with the other partnered-sex results it measured (Perry, 2020b; McNabney et al., 2020). That link comes from answers given at one time, so it cannot test the claim. The evidence on it is weighed on our page on whether porn can condition your arousal. How imagination compares with porn is the subject of our page on whether fantasizing is as bad as porn.

If masturbating, with or without porn, feels out of control or distressing, a doctor or a licensed mental health professional is the person to see. The same goes for a sexual difficulty that keeps going.

## References

- Karageorgou, C., & Agorastos, A. (2025a). From Onanism to Masturbation—A Comprehensive Overview on Matters of Behavioral Specificity, Hypotheses of Function and Associated Aspects of Pathology. International Journal of Sexual Health. https://doi.org/10.1080/19317611.2025.2562422
- McNabney, S. M., Hevesi, K., & Rowland, D. L. (2020). Effects of Pornography Use and Demographic Parameters on Sexual Response during Masturbation and Partnered Sex in Women. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17093130
- Perry, S. L. (2020b). Is the Link Between Pornography Use and Relational Happiness Really More About Masturbation? Results From Two National Surveys. Journal of sex research. https://doi.org/10.1080/00224499.2018.1556772

---

_Source: https://pornaddictionsolution.com/masturbation-with-vs-without-porn/ — educational content by Angus Munro, Clinical Psychologist (AHPRA Reg. PSY0001626434). This is general education, not individual clinical advice._
