Porn Addiction
Solution

Recovery guide

Is polyamory a sign of sex addiction?

No. Polyamory is an agreed way of arranging relationships. The World Health Organization’s diagnosis for problem sexual behavior asks whether a person can control that behavior and what it is costing them. How many partners someone has is not one of the things it looks at. So polyamory does not, by itself, establish sex addiction, the name people give to that kind of control problem.

This page is education, and it can’t diagnose you; only a clinician who assesses you can do that. ‘Sex addiction’ and ‘hypersexuality’ are not diagnoses in the WHO’s ICD-11 or in the DSM-5-TR; the closest ICD-11 diagnosis is compulsive sexual behavior disorder. You can still notice that your sexual behavior worries you, and that is worth taking seriously.

What is the difference between polyamory and sex addiction?

Dictionary.com defines polyamory as being in more than one serious romantic or sexual relationship at the same time. It adds that this happens with the knowledge and agreement of all partners. Compulsive sexual behavior disorder, or CSBD, is the World Health Organization’s diagnosis for a lasting pattern of failing to control intense, repetitive sexual urges. Its description does not single out any one kind of sexual behavior. The first definition is about who knows and who has agreed; the second is about control.

By the dictionary’s definition, an extra relationship that a partner has not agreed to is not polyamory. Interests and arrangements that everyone has agreed to do not, by themselves, establish a disorder. Repeated affairs kept hidden from a partner raise a different question from an agreed arrangement: whether repeated cheating comes from compulsion or from choice.

A one-time study of 866 people in relationships found that those in agreed non-monogamy were as sexually satisfied, with themselves and with their main partner, as monogamous people, and that those in non-monogamy a partner had not agreed to were the least sexually satisfied (Rodrigues et al., 2021). Because everyone was measured only once, the study shows how the groups compared, not which came first, and it did not look at sex addiction.

Polyamory is also not the same thing as promiscuity: Dictionary.com gives the sexual sense of promiscuous as having casual and indiscriminate, meaning not selective, sexual relationships.

Can a polyamorous person have compulsive sexual behavior?

Yes, in the same way as anyone else. ICD-11, the World Health Organization’s list of diagnoses, does not tie this diagnosis to any kind of relationship. It looks at whether a person can control intense sexual urges, and whether the behavior goes on even when it brings bad consequences. It also looks at whether the pattern brings marked distress or serious problems in daily life. Those questions apply in the same way to someone with several agreed partners, someone married to one person and someone who is single. Two people with the same number of partners can give very different answers to them. The same questions also separate a high sex drive from a disorder.

Some medical and psychiatric conditions can look like out-of-control sexual behavior; only a clinician can sort that out.

On the distress part of the description, ICD-11 adds this note: “Distress that is entirely related to moral judgments and disapproval about sexual impulses, urges, or behaviours is not sufficient to meet this requirement.”

Are therapists and other people biased against non-monogamy?

Some appear to be, at least when judging written cases. Studies in which therapists rated made-up clients found that their judgments differed with the client’s relationship pattern, and one of them found that which gender was rated more negatively depended on that pattern.

The first was an experiment. Marriage and family therapists, picked at random from the clinical members of an American professional association, were each given one of four written cases by chance. Every case described sex between two adults who had both agreed to it. What changed was whether the client was a man or a woman, and whether the client was married with one partner or single with varied partners. The study found that the 199 therapists who replied pathologized single clients with varied partners more than married clients with one partner (Hecker et al., 1995). To pathologize is to judge something as a sign of a disorder. Chance deciding who read which case makes it less likely that the groups differed from the start. Male therapists also tended to pathologize the cases more than female therapists did, a difference the study measured rather than set up.

A later survey asked 208 therapists, 92 licensed and 116 still in training, to rate “sex addiction” in made-up clients (Reddick et al., 2017). The survey found that women’s nonmonogamous behavior, meaning sex outside one exclusive relationship, was rated more negatively than men’s, while men’s monogamous behavior was rated more negatively than women’s.

Both studies found their differences in ratings of written cases, not in judgments about real clients, and the first is now many years old. The first study’s cases described single people with varied partners, not people in a polyamorous relationship that everyone had agreed to. The second study described its cases by exclusivity, the study’s own term, which does not say whether partners had agreed.

Beyond therapists, a set of social psychology studies, including ratings of descriptions of relationships, found that people rated monogamous relationships more positively than consensually non-monogamous ones, the agreed kind. In that work, the researchers found monogamous relationships rated more positively on every dimension measured, across diverse social groups, and even by people in consensually non-monogamous relationships themselves. The researchers describe the pattern as stigma, meaning shared disapproval, toward consensual non-monogamy. They also describe a halo effect around monogamy, meaning it was seen favorably across the board.

References

  • Hecker, L. L., Trepper, T. S., Wetchler, J. L., & Fontaine, K. L. (1995). The influence of therapist values, religiosity and gender in the initial assessment of sexual addiction by family therapists. American Journal of Family Therapy. https://doi.org/10.1080/01926189508251356
  • Reddick, G. T., Heiden-Rootes, K. M., & Brimhall, A. S. (2017). Therapists’ Assessments in Treating “Sex Addiction” and Their Relationship to Clients’ Gender, Relationship Status, and Exclusivity Status. Journal of marital and family therapy. https://doi.org/10.1111/jmft.12210
  • Rodrigues, D. L., Lopes, D., Dawson, K., de Visser, R., & Štulhofer, A. (2021). With or Without You: Associations Between Frequency of Internet Pornography Use and Sexual Relationship Outcomes for (Non)Consensual (Non)Monogamous Individuals. Archives of sexual behavior. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-020-01782-z

Sources

  1. POLYAMORY Definition & Meaning | Dictionary.com. Link
  2. PROMISCUOUS Definition & Meaning | Dictionary.com. Link
  3. The Fewer the Merrier?: Assessing Stigma Surrounding Consensually Non‐monogamous Romantic Relationships. Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy (abstract via Crossref). Link

Angus Munro

Clinical Psychologist, Sydney, Australia

Angus Munro is a clinical psychologist registered with AHPRA in Australia. He wrote the Porn Addiction Solution course.

Full profile and credentials