Porn Addiction
Solution

Recovery guide

Does having sex cancel NoFap benefits?

Whether sex with a partner cancels anything people say they get from NoFap has not been tested in any study found.

NoFap’s own site says going without porn, masturbation and orgasm altogether “includes barring orgasms with another person”, while another version lets people “engage in sex and have orgasms”. The rules for each version are on our page about having sex on NoFap. A rule about what breaks the challenge does not show whether having sex cancels the benefits people claim for NoFap.

Has research found any difference between sex and masturbation?

Yes, but only as a link. A study of 2,450 adults aged 18 to 60 from a 1996 national survey in Sweden found results suggesting that the things that went with frequent intercourse were mostly positive, while those that went with frequent masturbation and “impersonal sex” were typically undesirable (Långström & Hanson, 2006). It used interviews and questionnaires about sexual behavior, childhood, behavior problems and health. The people were chosen to represent the general population, not drawn from a clinic. Here, “went with” means the things tended to show up together in the same people.

Because each person was measured once, the survey shows a link, not which came first. It cannot tell whether frequent intercourse helps those other things along, or whether people who are already doing well simply have intercourse more often. Its findings are also about doing either thing often, not about doing it at all.

It cannot show that masturbation does harm, either. Nobody in it was asked to stop or to swap one for the other, so it says nothing about what changes when someone does.

NoFap’s own site also says many people follow its no-orgasm version by default, because they do not have partners or are not sexually active.

Will you lose NoFap’s claimed benefits if you have sex?

No study was found that tested whether sex with a partner, or an orgasm during sex, cancels, reduces or resets any of the benefits people claim for NoFap. Whether those benefits are real is a separate question, and our page on NoFap’s claimed benefits and the evidence looks at it. Untested is not the same as disproved.

One person’s experience cannot settle the question, because nobody can see how the same stretch of time would have gone without the sex.

One claim ties those benefits to testosterone, the main male sex hormone: the idea is that not masturbating raises it. Healthline, a consumer health site, says in its article on NoFap’s benefits that “there’s no evidence linking the effect of masturbation on testosterone levels to any of the benefits listed”. That claim gets a closer look on our page about NoFap and testosterone.

Does sex affect semen retention?

Only if it ends in ejaculation. Medical News Today, a health news site, says semen retention “refers to when a person intentionally avoids ejaculating”. The same site says a person can do this by “abstaining from any sexual activity, stopping before the point of ejaculation, or teaching themselves to orgasm without ejaculating”.

A systematic Google search for online ejaculation-training courses found eleven, none taught by anyone claiming standardized medical or mental-health credentials (Prause, 2023b). The paper reported that, despite no scientific evidence, these courses claim to improve various aspects of men’s health. Looking at what courses advertise cannot show whether holding back ejaculation has any effect on the body. How retention’s rules compare with NoFap’s is set out in our page comparing the two.

References

  • Långström, N., & Hanson, R. K. (2006). High rates of sexual behavior in the general population: correlates and predictors. Archives of sexual behavior. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-006-8993-y
  • Prause, N. (2023b). Online ejaculation training programs promote non-evidence-based treatment of male sexual dysfunction. International Journal of Impotence Research. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41443-023-00780-8

Sources

  1. NoFap benefits (Healthline). Link
  2. Semen retention (What is semen retention?). Medical News Today. Link
  3. How to Quit Porn (rebooting). NoFap LLC. Link

Angus Munro

Clinical Psychologist, Sydney, Australia

Angus Munro is a clinical psychologist registered with AHPRA in Australia. He wrote the Porn Addiction Solution course.

Full profile and credentials