Recovery guide
Can you use porn in moderation if it feels like an addiction, or do you have to quit completely?
If porn has come to feel like an addiction, the research has not ruled out that you can use it in moderation, but the question is still open. A trial that tests both a moderation goal and a goal of stopping completely has published its plan but has not yet reported any results (Stark et al., 2024). Until it does, the nearest evidence comes from research on alcohol problems, where trials have compared a goal of drinking less with a goal of not drinking at all. Which goal you aim for stays your own choice.
This page is education, and it can’t diagnose you; only a clinician who assesses you can do that. ‘Porn addiction’ is not a diagnosis in the WHO’s ICD-11 or in the DSM-5-TR; the closest ICD-11 diagnosis is compulsive sexual behavior disorder. You can still notice that your use worries you, and that is worth taking seriously.
Has anyone tested a moderation goal against stopping completely for porn?
A randomized trial of a program called PornLoS was planned to test two versions with different goals, no porn or reduced porn use, each against the usual cognitive-behavioral care and against a waitlist; its published protocol reported that plan and no results (Stark et al., 2024). Randomized means chance decides which group each person joins. The cited paper reported the trial’s protocol: the study’s plan, written down and published in advance.
The trial’s protocol reported four groups. Two groups get versions of the same cognitive-behavioral program, a talking approach that works on thoughts and actions. The two versions differ in their goal: no porn at all, or reduced use. The other groups get the usual cognitive-behavioral treatment or join a waitlist, a group that waits its turn. The planned sample is 316 people across eight study sites. All of them will have what the researchers call pornography use disorder, which they class as a type of compulsive sexual behavior disorder. Some might expect a reduced-use goal to be out of reach for them, but the trial is set up to test that goal with them. The trial’s main measure of success is whether people no longer meet the criteria for that disorder at the end of the program.
Some published randomized trials of psychological help for problem porn use or hypersexual disorder reported success mainly as fewer symptoms or less viewing, with full stopping, where given, as a separate result (Hallberg et al., 2019; Crosby & Twohig, 2016). Their results are described in the research on psychological help.
A small study reported a suggestion from its authors: aiming at acceptance rather than at no use at all. It is a case series, a close look at a few individual people with no comparison group. Six men who felt their porn use was a problem took part in a mindfulness program. Mindfulness means paying attention to the present moment on purpose. From these six cases, the authors suggested that accepting oneself and one’s porn use may be a more realistic, practical and attainable goal than stopping completely, though the study did not test this (Sniewski & Farvid, 2019).
Does a moderation goal hold up for alcohol addiction?
Henssler and colleagues searched for and pooled twenty-two alcohol studies, with 4,204 adult patients, comparing a controlled-drinking goal with a goal of not drinking at all. Controlled drinking means aiming to drink less, rather than not at all. Their systematic review and meta-analysis, published in the journal Addiction, found no statistically significant difference between the goals in the five randomized trials among them.
In plain terms, any gap between the goals in those trials could be explained by chance.
In the randomized trials, chance decided who got which goal. In non-randomized studies where people chose their own goal, the no-drinking goal came out ahead. That edge did not show where the treatment was built for the chosen goal, or in studies whose methods made a tilted result unlikely.
The authors concluded that the evidence does not support a no-drinking goal as the only approach. In their view, controlled drinking, particularly with specific psychotherapy, appears a viable option where a no-drinking approach is not applicable. What holds for drinking may not carry over to porn use.
Does a more severe problem call for a different goal?
Not clearly, at least in alcohol research: the review above found results did not clearly depend on how severe the drinking problem was. A UK trial of treatment for alcohol problems, reported by Heather, Adamson and colleagues, found that people who aimed to stop drinking completely differed from the rest in several ways.
At the start, 742 people in that trial were noted as aiming, or not aiming, to stop drinking completely. Those aiming to stop were more likely to be female and unemployed. They were more likely to report drinking more heavily but less often, more alcohol problems, and more mental and physical ill-health. They were also more likely to have been through detoxification, medical care while coming off alcohol, in the previous two weeks. They were more likely to report less support for their drinking from people around them, and more confidence about resisting heavy drinking. The strongest predictors of that aim were gender, drinking pattern, recent detoxification and social support for drinking. Having more alcohol problems was among those differences, but not among the strongest predictors.
Does the goal a person prefers affect the outcome?
In the alcohol trial described above, people who first preferred to stop completely had a better outcome than those who did not. The gap was clearer at 3 months and still evident at 12 months. It came almost entirely from more days without drinking. A modest edge in how much they drank disappeared once the researchers allowed for how the groups differed at the start. People who preferred to stop were also more likely to end up not drinking, and those who did not were more likely to end up drinking without problems. Because people picked their own goals, this compares people who chose differently, and it can’t show that the goal itself made the difference.
The trial’s authors recommended that a person’s own drinking goals be discussed at the start of treatment, as a basis for negotiation. They also recommended that clinicians, the health workers giving the care, support a change of goal as an ordinary part of treatment.
The practical questions have pages of their own: how to use less day to day, whether to stop all at once or step down and the steps for stopping.
References
- Crosby, J. M., & Twohig, M. P. (2016). Acceptance and Commitment Therapy for Problematic Internet Pornography Use: A Randomized Trial. Behavior therapy. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2016.02.001
- Hallberg, J., Kaldo, V., Arver, S., Dhejne, C., Jokinen, J., & Öberg, K. G. (2019). A Randomized Controlled Study of Group-Administered Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Hypersexual Disorder in Men. The journal of sexual medicine. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2019.03.005
- Sniewski, L., & Farvid, P. (2019). Abstinence or Acceptance? A Case Series of Men’s Experiences With an Intervention Addressing Self-Perceived Problematic Pornography Use. Sexual Addiction & Compulsivity The Journal of Treatment and Prevention. https://doi.org/10.1080/10720162.2019.1645058
- Stark, R., Markert, C., Golder, S., Psarros, R., Discher, J. P., Khatib, S., Metzger, J., Palmer, S., Rechmann, J., Storz, F., Walter, B., & Allard, S. (2024). The PornLoS Treatment Program: Study protocol of a new psychotherapeutic approach for treating pornography use disorder. Journal of behavioral addictions. https://doi.org/10.1556/2006.2024.00046
Sources
- Controlled drinking-non-abstinent versus abstinent treatment goals in alcohol use disorder: a systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression. Addiction (journal abstract). Link
- Initial preference for drinking goal in the treatment of alcohol problems: I. Baseline differences between abstinence and non-abstinence groups. Alcohol and Alcoholism (journal abstract). Link
- Initial preference for drinking goal in the treatment of alcohol problems: II. Treatment outcomes. Alcohol and Alcoholism (journal abstract). Link