Recovery guide
Should you go NoFap cold turkey or quit porn gradually?
Taken overall, stopping all at once did at least as well as cutting down first in trials with smokers. No trial in people who use porn was found that compared stopping all at once with cutting down first. Cutting down can stall for a plain reason. Each decision about how much is enough is another chance to stay at the level you’re at.
What does going cold turkey ask of you, compared with cutting down?
Going NoFap cold turkey, stopping all at once, asks for one clear line from the first day. There’s nothing left to decide about how much, because the answer is none. Cutting down asks for something different: a run of smaller decisions about how much is enough, and a point where the cutting down ends. The two routes put the effort in different places.
Take stopping all at once first. The line is the same on a quiet weekend as on a bad night at the end of a hard week. When the urge comes, there’s no question to settle about whether this time counts, because that was settled at the start. That’s what the route offers: clarity. The cost is that the whole change arrives at once. There’s no gentler middle stage, and nothing familiar is kept back while you get used to the difference.
Cutting down works the other way around. The first step is smaller, and some of what’s familiar stays for a while, which can make it feel more possible to begin. What changes is the question you face each time. Instead of a settled no, the question becomes: is this one of the times that’s still allowed? That question comes back every time the urge does, and each answer is a fresh decision.
Cutting down also needs somewhere to end. Without that end point, nothing says when the cutting down is finished. Neither route ends with the first decision, though. A clear line has to hold on later days too, and a taper has to reach its end.
The practical side of cutting down is in our guide to cutting down on porn.
Why can cutting down stall?
Because the route keeps putting the same choice in front of you, and staying at the current level is always one of the options. When enough of the answers come out as “not yet,” the level stops moving down. Nothing in the route itself pushes it lower.
A first target can start out as a step and end up as the new normal. Staying there asks for nothing new, while each move lower asks for another round of effort. So there may be no single night when the plan broke. It just stopped moving.
That’s a reason cutting down can stall, not a count of how often it does. It also means a stalled taper can come from how the route is built, not only from the person on it.
In NoFap community threads, one member says that for them total abstinence led to failure after failure. One post says that easing off makes it easy to get stuck somewhere comfortable, and one says that going quickly or slowly matters less than keeping going. These are members’ own accounts and views, so they show what the choice can feel like from the inside, not which route works.
What does research say about stopping all at once versus cutting down?
Overall, cutting down first gave smokers no advantage over stopping all at once. A trial in smokers, published in Annals of Internal Medicine, found that stopping abruptly did better, and a Cochrane review found that neither route came out ahead.
The trial included 697 adult smokers at primary care clinics in England. It assigned them by chance either to stop abruptly on a quit day or to cut down by 75% over the two weeks before that day. The study found that those assigned to stop abruptly were more often confirmed as not smoking, both at four weeks (49.0% against 39.2%) and at six months (22.0% against 15.5%). Both groups had support from nurses and used nicotine replacement products before and after the quit day, so the main planned difference between them was the route. Assigning people by chance makes it unlikely that the two groups differed at the start in ways that matter, so in this trial a gap between them at the end points to the route itself. The authors concluded that smokers who quit abruptly are more likely to stay stopped than those who cut down first, even smokers who at first prefer to cut down.
The Cochrane review, a structured search that gathers all the studies on one question, compared advice to cut down before quitting with quitting abruptly. It found that neither approach gave better quit rates than the other, across 22 studies with 9219 participants. The reviewers rated their certainty in that result as moderate, not high, because the result was imprecise. The review carries more weight than the single trial, because it pools 22 studies. A subgroup analysis in the review found some evidence that cutting down first may give better quit rates than stopping abruptly when varenicline is used as an aid to cutting down.
These are findings about smoking, and they may not carry over to porn.
Does the route you choose decide the goal?
No. You might aim for no porn at all, or for using it only now and then. That goal is a separate decision from whether you stop all at once or step by step. Whether occasional use can work as an end point is the subject of our page on using porn in moderation.
The two questions meet in one place. Stopping all at once starts at zero. Cutting down has to stop somewhere, and the goal is what decides where. Choosing to cut down first doesn’t mean you’ve settled on occasional use, because a taper can run all the way to none.
A small study of a brief online program for cutting down porn use found that 76% of the 25 who enrolled set a goal of stopping completely (Rodda & Luoto, 2022).
For the wider picture of stopping, beyond the choice of route, see our main guide to stopping porn.
References
- Rodda, S. N., & Luoto, S. (2022). The Feasibility and Impact of a Brief Internet Intervention for Pornography Reduction. Sexual Health & Compulsivity. https://doi.org/10.1080/26929953.2022.2153772
Sources
- How effective is gradual abstinence? NoFap forum. Link
- Gradual Versus Abrupt Smoking Cessation: A Randomized, Controlled Noninferiority Trial. Europe PMC (record of Annals of Internal Medicine 164(9):585-592; Lindson-Hawley N et al). Link
- Smoking reduction interventions for smoking cessation. Europe PMC (record of Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2019, issue 9, CD013183.pub2; Lindson N; Klemperer E; Hong B; Ordonez-Mena JM; Aveyard P). Link
- cold turkey vs a gradual descent. NoFap forum. Link