Recovery guide
Does gratitude help with porn recovery?
Being thankful on purpose has beaten doing nothing extra in studies of well-being, but those studies measured how people felt, not whether they stopped watching porn. The research found so far has not tested how gratitude helps with porn recovery, or whether it does; the closest is a survey of people in a fellowship for compulsive sexual behavior, which found that gratitude was linked to well-being in that group (Wnuk et al., 2024). Compulsive sexual behavior here means sexual behavior that a person keeps repeating and struggles to control. The survey found that gratitude went with higher life satisfaction and more positive feelings among the members it surveyed.
Dictionary.com defines gratitude as “the quality or feeling of being grateful or thankful.” A gratitude exercise is a task built around that feeling, such as listing things a person is grateful for.
What does gratitude research show?
In well-being research, gratitude exercises did better than doing nothing extra, and better than some other activities, on how well people felt. Against an exercise designed to help in its own right, they did as well, but not better. A separate review found a small effect on symptoms of depression and anxiety.
What did the reviews of many studies find?
Davis and colleagues, writing in the Journal of Counseling Psychology, started from an earlier review by Wood, Froh and Geraghty that cast doubt on how well gratitude exercises work. Their series of meta-analyses, studies that pool the results of many earlier studies, found that gratitude exercises did better than a measurement-only control on psychological well-being (d = .31; 5 studies), but not on gratitude itself. The outcomes they looked at were gratitude, anxiety and psychological well-being, meaning how well people felt their lives were going. A measurement-only control is a group that just fills in the same questionnaires, and d is an effect size, a measure of how big a difference was. A figure of zero would mean no difference, and the further a figure sits from zero, the bigger the difference.
Against an alternative activity, meaning a different task done instead, gratitude exercises did better on gratitude (d = .46; 15 studies) and on psychological well-being (d = .17; 20 studies), but not on anxiety. They also did better on well-being than an activity-matched comparison, a task matched to the gratitude exercise in what people did (d = .14; 18 studies). Against a psychologically active comparison, an exercise meant to help people in its own right, they did as well but not better (d = -.03; 9 studies).
Cregg and Cheavens, writing in the Journal of Happiness Studies, pooled 27 studies of 3,675 people. They found that gratitude exercises had a small effect on symptoms of depression and anxiety. The effect showed right after the programs ended (g = − 0.29) and at a later follow-up (g = − 0.23), where g, like d, measures how big a difference was. The effects were larger in studies that compared gratitude with a waitlist, a group that waits its turn, than in studies with an active comparison. The authors call the effects relatively modest.
This is why the comparison group matters so much. Beating people who only fill in questionnaires, or who wait their turn, shows that a gratitude exercise does more than nothing. Beating another exercise built to help is the fairer test of whether gratitude itself adds something, beyond simply having a task to do.
What did the earlier experiments find?
Emmons and McCullough, writing in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, tested a grateful outlook in three experiments, two of them with weekly or daily mood records. They found that people assigned by chance to list what they were grateful for did better than the comparison groups on several, though not all, well-being measures. The other groups listed hassles, or neutral events, or comparisons with other people. A third study assigned people with neuromuscular disease, illnesses of the nerves and muscles, to a gratitude or a control condition. The effect on positive mood appeared to be the most robust finding. The authors suggest that a conscious focus on blessings may have benefits for people’s feelings and for their relationships with others.
Does gratitude make people more patient in money choices?
In a laboratory study of money choices, from emotion and decision research, DeSteno and colleagues found that feeling grateful reduced impatience, even when real money was at stake. Impatience here means valuing a reward too little just because it comes later, which the authors say the human mind tends to do. The effect was distinct from that of feeling generally happy. The authors, writing in Psychological Science, say this challenges the view that people must hold back their feelings through effortful self-control to make more patient choices about money.
Did any of this research test porn use?
The fellowship survey found that gratitude went with well-being among the members it surveyed, but it did not measure porn use. No trial was found that tested a gratitude practice in people who use porn or in people with compulsive sexual behavior; the research found is one-time survey data from members of one recovery fellowship. Unknown is not the same as disproved.
How do recovery programs say gratitude helps?
The Hazelden Betty Ford Foundation is a treatment provider writing about recovery from alcohol and other drugs, not porn. It says gratitude “helps you notice progress instead of problems, reducing stress and creating a sense of hope.” It also describes noticing “the little things” and telling someone how much you value them. That is a provider’s account of why gratitude matters, not a measured result.
What did the fellowship survey find?
The fellowship survey from the top of this page studied 80 members of Sexaholics Anonymous, a mutual-aid fellowship that works through 12 steps, in Poland (72 men and 8 women), and found links between steps completed, spiritual growth, gratitude and well-being (Wnuk et al., 2024). The survey found that completing more of the fellowship’s 12 steps went directly with fewer negative feelings, and also with more spiritual growth. Its questionnaires covered spiritual experiences in daily life, gratitude, life satisfaction, and positive and negative feelings. It also asked each member how many of the 12 steps they had completed. Life satisfaction means how content people are with their lives as a whole.
Spiritual growth went with higher life satisfaction and fewer negative feelings. Through gratitude, spiritual growth also went with higher life satisfaction and more positive feelings. The researchers found these links with a path analysis, a way of testing how several measures link up with one another. Put simply, members who reported more spiritual growth also tended to report more gratitude, and more gratitude went with feeling better about their lives. Gratitude here was a feeling measured by questionnaire, not an exercise the members were given. As a survey of people who chose to join, with no follow-up and no comparison group, it shows a link, not which came first.
What does a gratitude practice look like?
Gratitude practices are small acts of noticing and thanking. Harvard Health Publishing, from Harvard Medical School, lists several kinds in its article “Giving thanks can make you happier”: writing a thank-you note, thanking someone mentally, keeping a gratitude journal, counting your blessings, praying and meditating.
Some of these stay private, such as thanking someone in your head or counting your blessings, and some reach another person, such as a thank-you note. Counting your blessings means taking stock of the good things in your life, and a gratitude journal is a written record of them. The experiments described above used a written kind, listing things people were grateful for. What these kinds share is a turn of attention toward what is going well, the same point the Hazelden Betty Ford Foundation makes about noticing progress.
In one study Harvard Health describes, people who wrote a few sentences about gratitude each week were more optimistic and felt better about their lives after 10 weeks. The same article reports that middle-aged divorced women who kept gratitude journals were no more satisfied with their lives than those who did not.
Is gratitude enough on its own?
On well-being, as the comparisons above show, gratitude did as well as other exercises built to help, but not better. That does not make the well-being findings useless: feeling better day to day is worth having for its own sake.
Skills for stress and hard feelings are covered on our page about skills people use in recovery, and physical exercise has its own page too. The wider plan for stopping is set out in our guide to stopping watching porn.
References
- Wnuk, M., Krentzman, A. R., & Charzyńska, E. (2024). The 12-Step Pathway to Spiritual Growth and Gratitude and Its Relationship With Well-Being Among the Members of Sexaholics Anonymous in Poland. Journal of religion and health. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-023-01892-7
Sources
- Thankful for the little things: A meta-analysis of gratitude interventions. Journal of Counseling Psychology (journal abstract). Link
- Gratitude Interventions: Effective Self-help? A Meta-analysis of the Impact on Symptoms of Depression and Anxiety. Journal of Happiness Studies (journal abstract, publisher page). Link
- Counting blessings versus burdens: an experimental investigation of gratitude and subjective well-being in daily life. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (journal abstract). Link
- Gratitude: a tool for reducing economic impatience. Psychological Science (journal abstract). Link
- Gratitude in Recovery: Why It Matters. Hazelden Betty Ford Foundation. Link
- Giving thanks can make you happier. Harvard Health Publishing (Harvard Medical School). Link
- GRATITUDE Definition & Meaning | Dictionary.com. Link
Related guides
A self-directed video course by Angus Munro, a clinical psychologist registered in Australia. Thirty-two video lessons, a one-page summary for each, and a plan you build for yourself.
Angus Munro wrote this page and sells the Porn Addiction Solution course. This page is general education; it can’t tell you what’s right for your situation.