Porn Addiction
Solution

Recovery guide

Why am I having nightmares on NoFap or since quitting porn?

Stress is one possible reason for nightmares on NoFap, an online community’s name for giving up porn and masturbation. No study was found that measured dreaming, nightmares included, in people who stopped porn. So the best clues come from what sleep medicine knows about bad dreams in general. MedlinePlus and the Sleep Foundation list stress among the triggers of nightmares. Sleep science also describes REM rebound, a temporary rise in REM sleep, but StatPearls, a clinical reference text, reports that people with it may report more frequent vivid dreams, not nightmares as such. Nightmares don’t show how quitting is going, but frequent ones, or ones that wear down your sleep or days, are a question for a doctor.

Has anyone studied nightmares after quitting porn?

Nothing was found on nightmares as such. The only related data found are one-time self-reports, meaning people’s own answers about themselves on a single occasion. Those self-reports are described on our page about vivid dreams after quitting.

Untested is not the same as disproved. If you have noticed bad dreams since you stopped, the missing research doesn’t mean you imagined them. It doesn’t show that quitting is the reason, either.

Whether bad dreams count as withdrawal, a word some people use for unpleasant effects when stopping something, is weighed on our page about withdrawal.

What causes nightmares?

Stress is one trigger that MedlinePlus and the Sleep Foundation both name. MedlinePlus is the US National Library of Medicine’s health information site. It defines a nightmare as “a bad dream that brings out strong feelings of fear, terror, distress, or anxiety.” Adults get them too: MedlinePlus notes that nightmares may continue into adulthood.

The Sleep Foundation, a sleep-health information site, says, “Sad, traumatic, or worrisome situations that induce stress and fear may provoke nightmares.” MedlinePlus gives a similar list. It says one or more nightmares over a short time may be caused by a major life event. The examples it gives are the loss of a loved one or a traumatic event. Increased stress at home or work is on the same list.

In sleep research, a review of earlier studies by Levin and Nielsen reported that nightmares are associated with increased stress, meaning the two tend to go together. The review, in the journal Psychological Bulletin, also linked nightmares with being female and being younger. The reviewers propose that how often and how badly people have nightmares reflect daily emotional pressure and a tendency to react to events with distress.

All of this is general sleep science, not a finding about people having bad dreams on NoFap.

The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, a US government health institute, says dreaming usually happens during rapid eye movement (REM) sleep. StatPearls says people with REM rebound, a temporary rise in REM sleep after it has been cut short, may report more frequent vivid dreams. That is about vivid dreams, the kind that feel especially clear and real, rather than nightmares as such. Our page about vivid dreams after quitting explains REM rebound.

Sex dreams after quitting are a separate topic, with their own page.

Do nightmares mean something is wrong, and when do they need a doctor?

A nightmare is not a measure of how quitting is going, in either direction.

Waking from a nightmare can leave you shaken. When you are working hard to change a habit, a frightening dream can also feel like a verdict on how that is going. MedlinePlus and the Sleep Foundation spell out clearer markers.

MedlinePlus says to contact a health care provider if you have nightmares more than once a week. It also says to get in touch if nightmares stop you from getting a good night’s rest, or from keeping up with your daily activities, for a long period. The Sleep Foundation’s list of reasons to talk to your doctor includes nightmares that happen more than once a week. The same list adds nightmares that affect your sleep, mood, or daily activity. None of these points depends on knowing why the nightmares started, so the question about quitting doesn’t need an answer first. A doctor is the place to start, because a doctor can look at your own sleep and health. That holds even if you’re unsure whether your nightmares meet these markers.

MedlinePlus adds that repeated nightmares may also be a sign of other conditions, among them ones linked to trauma or to more severe anxiety. So nightmares that seem tied to a past trauma are a reason to see a doctor or a licensed mental-health professional. So are repeated nightmares that come with more severe anxiety. A licensed mental-health professional means someone such as a psychologist, counselor or psychiatrist who is licensed or registered where you live. What is known about anxiety after quitting is set out on its own page.

In a position paper on treating nightmare disorder in adults, a task force from the American Academy of Sleep Medicine weighed the studies and its own clinical expertise, and reported that image rehearsal therapy is recommended for nightmare disorder and for nightmares associated with post-traumatic stress disorder.

The Sleep Foundation says the approach “involves rewriting a recurring nightmare into a script that is rewritten and then rehearsed when awake.” It says the aim is “to change how it unfolds and impacts the sleeper.” Rehearsed here means practiced. The description is about a recurring nightmare, meaning one that repeats.

This is a clinical approach, described here so you know it exists, not as steps to try at home. A doctor or a sleep specialist can say whether it suits your nightmares. Sleep habits while quitting are a separate topic, covered on our page about trouble sleeping since you quit.

Sources

  1. Nightmares (Sleep Foundation). Link
  2. Nightmares: MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia. MedlinePlus (National Library of Medicine), A.D.A.M. encyclopedia. Link
  3. Disturbed dreaming, posttraumatic stress disorder, and affect distress: a review and neurocognitive model. Psychological Bulletin (journal abstract). Link
  4. How Sleep Works - Sleep Phases and Stages. NHLBI (NIH). Link
  5. REM Rebound Effect (StatPearls). StatPearls Publishing, on NCBI Bookshelf (NLM, NIH); authors Joshua Feriante and Shantanu Singh. Link
  6. Position Paper for the Treatment of Nightmare Disorder in Adults: An American Academy of Sleep Medicine Position Paper. Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine (journal abstract). Link

Angus Munro

Clinical Psychologist, Sydney, Australia

Angus Munro is a clinical psychologist registered with AHPRA in Australia. He wrote the Porn Addiction Solution course.

Full profile and credentials