Recovery guide
What is 'out of control sexual behavior' (OCSB)?
Out of control sexual behavior (OCSB) is a sexual health term for consensual sexual urges, thoughts or behaviors that feel out of control. The term is also the name of a sexual health model. In a book chapter, its authors suggested that the model offers a sexual health alternative to disorder-based models such as sex addiction, one view in a contested debate (Vigorito & Braun-Harvey, 2017). OCSB is a way of framing the problem. The World Health Organization’s diagnosis for the same kind of problem has a different name: compulsive sexual behavior disorder, or CSBD.
Where does the term come from?
The OCSB model comes from Douglas Braun-Harvey and Michael Vigorito, whose book, Treating Out of Control Sexual Behavior: Rethinking Sex Addiction, is published by Springer Publishing Company. Springer gives the book’s release date as November 5, 2015. The phrase itself was in use before that, in a theoretical paper whose author concluded that, in his opinion, it was one of the more fitting general terms (Bancroft, 2008).
Bancroft concluded that addiction and compulsivity (compulsivity means repeating something despite wanting to stop) may explain some cases but are not helpful general labels (Bancroft, 2008). This is one position in a contested debate. Instead, Bancroft reported his own preference for broad terms that focus on whether a person can control their sexual behavior, not how much sex they have or want. He also reported his view that it was too early for one overall definition to guide clinical care, until the different patterns of the problem, and their likely sources, are better understood.
In a later chapter, Braun-Harvey and Vigorito reported their definition of the term: a sexual health problem in which consensual sexual urges, thoughts or behaviors feel out of control (Vigorito & Braun-Harvey, 2017). They frame it as a behavior problem within the normal range of sexual expression. The definition rests on the word “feel”: it starts from the person’s own sense of being out of control.
Neither the theoretical paper nor the chapter reported any data from people. They set out ways of thinking about the problem, so neither can show that its way of thinking is correct.
Why does the OCSB model avoid the addiction label?
Its authors suggested that the problem be defined in sexual health terms (Vigorito & Braun-Harvey, 2017). They offer the model as a sexual health alternative to models built around a disorder, among them sex addiction and hypersexual behavior, though this is one position in a contested debate.
The chapter reported that its authors adapt a dual-process model to describe how the behavior may come to feel out of control. The idea is that a person can have motivations that compete with each other. In their account, that competition may disrupt the person’s felt sense of control. The chapter reported this as an idea and did not test it.
AASECT, the American Association of Sexuality Educators, Counselors and Therapists, is a professional body that takes its own position on the label, separate from the OCSB model. AASECT says it “does not find sufficient empirical evidence to support the classification of sex addiction or porn addiction as a mental health disorder.” So it sees too little research support for calling either one a mental health disorder. This is the first point in AASECT’s position statement on sex addiction, and it is one professional body’s view.
Addiction-based models of the problem exist alongside the OCSB model. You can read the case for and against calling porn use an addiction.
How does the model handle values?
It is built on sexual health principles: Springer Publishing Company says the book promotes them “as the framework to envision and guide men’s sexual behavior change.” The book’s page on the Vigorito Counseling & Consulting website also speaks of “protecting client sexual rights and welcoming sexual diversity.”
Michael Aaron, writing on a Psychology Today blog, said the authors had developed “a six-fold model of Sexual Health Principles.” His summary lists them as consent, non-exploitative, safe, honest, shared values and mutually pleasurable.
Research on values conflict and porn use is covered in our guide to what porn addiction means.
ICD-11, the World Health Organization’s list of diagnoses, has its own rule on values. Distress that is “entirely related to moral judgments and disapproval” about sexual urges or behaviors is not sufficient to meet CSBD’s distress requirement. That rule sits with the rest of the ICD-11 criteria.
How does OCSB relate to CSBD and porn addiction?
OCSB is a sexual health framing. CSBD is a formal diagnosis with set requirements. “Porn addiction” is the everyday term for porn use that feels out of control, and it is not a diagnosis. Porn use like that can fit the OCSB definition given above, and it can also fall under CSBD.
OCSB starts from how out of control the behavior feels to the person. CSBD works differently: porn use falls under it only when it meets that diagnosis’s requirements.
Whether someone’s sexual behavior meets the diagnosis is a question for a doctor or licensed mental health professional who can look at that person’s own case.
References
- Bancroft, J. (2008). Sexual behavior that is “out of control”: a theoretical conceptual approach. The Psychiatric clinics of North America. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psc.2008.06.009
- Vigorito, M. A., & Braun-Harvey, D. (2017). Out of control sexual behaviour. Routledge eBooks. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315639512-36
Sources
- Treating Out of Control Sexual Behavior | Springer Publishing Company. Link
- AASECT Position on Sex Addiction. AASECT (American Association of Sexuality Educators, Counselors and Therapists). Link
- Treating Out of Control Sexual Behavior - Rethinking Sex Addiction (Vigorito Counseling & Consulting LLC). Link
- Yes, It Is Time to Finally Move on From Sex Addiction. Psychology Today (Standard Deviations blog), by Michael Aaron, Ph.D. Link