Porn Addiction
Solution

Recovery guide

Porn addiction vs masturbation addiction: what is the difference?

They overlap, but they are not the same problem. The difference between porn addiction and masturbation addiction lies in what a person struggles to control: porn use, or masturbation itself, which can happen with or without porn. Researchers can measure the two separately. For both, what marks a problem is a pattern rather than how often. That pattern is failing again and again to rein in the urge, carrying on despite harm, and real distress or disruption to daily life.

This page is education, and it can’t diagnose you; only a clinician who assesses you can do that. ‘Porn addiction’ is not a diagnosis in the WHO’s ICD-11 or in the DSM-5-TR; the closest ICD-11 diagnosis is compulsive sexual behavior disorder. You can still notice that your use worries you, and that is worth taking seriously.

Masturbation addiction is not a formal diagnosis either; like porn addiction, it is an everyday term. Compulsive sexual behavior disorder, a diagnosis in ICD-11 (the World Health Organization’s list of diagnoses), takes in any sexual behavior a person persistently fails to control. So that one diagnosis covers masturbation and porn use alike, which is also why porn addiction and sex addiction overlap.

How do researchers tell porn use and masturbation apart?

Excessive masturbation has a questionnaire of its own. One team built the Excessive Masturbation Scale and tested it in two separate samples of 146 and 255 people (Driemeyer et al., 2018). The study found two parts to the problem that held up in both samples: using masturbation to cope, and losing control over it. Checking a questionnaire in a second, separate group shows whether its parts hold up or were a fluke of the first group.

Neither part is a count of how often someone masturbates.

The researchers built the scale because work in this area had focused on problem porn use and on sexual behavior problems in general. Specific parts of these problems, masturbation among them, had been widely neglected. The team found the scale measured well and called it a promising basis for further research.

In a random-sample survey of 4,160 Norwegian women and men aged 18 to 89, more porn use was one of several things that went with masturbating more often, alongside being younger and having more variety in their sex lives (Fischer & Træen, 2022). The same survey found that distress about sex and a negative body image went more clearly with being unhappy with one’s sex life. That was the general population, not people seeking help, so it describes ordinary sex lives rather than problem use.

Because the two can be measured apart, a concern can sit with porn, with masturbation, or with both. Masturbation can also be looked at on its own terms, without assuming porn is behind it.

Does masturbating often mean there is a problem?

No. How often someone masturbates, or watches porn, does not by itself make a disorder, and masturbation itself is not one. High sexual desire is not a disorder either. Some people simply want sex more than others, and wanting it often is different from being unable to control it.

The WHO’s description sets no number of times a day or a week. It is built around control, harm and distress, and nothing in it depends on gender. So the same number can mean very different things for two different people, depending on whether it comes with those problems.

Three things are worth keeping apart: feeling that your own habit is a problem, scoring high on a questionnaire, and being diagnosed by a clinician. A high score on a questionnaire, including the masturbation scale above, is not a diagnosis.

When does masturbation without porn become a concern?

When it shows the same pattern that marks a problem with porn: losing control, keeping going despite harm, and distress. Porn does not have to be involved for that pattern to appear.

In a survey of 12,271 people in Finland, those who masturbated more or less often than they wanted reported more distress about their sex lives, women and men alike (Huang et al., 2023). The study also found that different definitions of problem masturbation counted different shares of people as having it. And some people who masturbated less often than average still felt it was a problem for them.

The survey asked about masturbation, not porn use, so its results describe masturbation on its own and do not carry over to porn.

The same pattern test applies to someone who has stopped watching porn but still masturbates often. What counts as a lot, and where the averages sit, is covered on our page about how much masturbation is too much.

Can porn addiction lead to compulsive masturbation?

Surveys can show whether porn use and masturbation go together, but not which one comes first. An online study in three European countries found that, among 596 heterosexual men in relationships who all had lowered sexual desire, frequent porn users were more likely to report frequent masturbation, as were men with sexual boredom or low intimacy in their relationship (Carvalheira et al., 2015). The researchers describe a pattern of porn-related masturbation that can be separate from desire for a partner.

That leaves several readings open: porn might push masturbation up, people who already masturbate often might turn to porn more, or something else might push up both. Porn use and masturbation were measured by how often they happened, and frequent use is not the same as lost control. The study found the link between frequent porn use and frequent masturbation in a narrow sample of coupled heterosexual men with lowered desire, so the result cannot be stretched to women or to men in general.

The shorthand that groups porn, masturbation and orgasm together has its own page: what PMO addiction means.

Which is more harmful: porn or masturbation?

Whether either one becomes a problem depends on the pattern described at the top, not on which one it is or how often it happens. Where that pattern does harm, it can show up in family life, social life, work or study.

Wanting to change a habit for reasons of one’s own is a goal a person sets for themselves, and it does not depend on any diagnosis.

References

  • Carvalheira, A., Træen, B., & Stulhofer, A. (2015). Masturbation and Pornography Use Among Coupled Heterosexual Men With Decreased Sexual Desire: How Many Roles of Masturbation?. Journal of sex & marital therapy. https://doi.org/10.1080/0092623x.2014.958790
  • Driemeyer, W., Snagowski, J., Laier, C., Schwarz, M., & Brand, M. (2018). Operationalization of Excessive Masturbation—Development of the EMS. Sexual Addiction & Compulsivity The Journal of Treatment and Prevention. https://doi.org/10.1080/10720162.2018.1495586
  • Fischer, N., & Træen, B. (2022). A Seemingly Paradoxical Relationship Between Masturbation Frequency and Sexual Satisfaction. Archives of sexual behavior. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-022-02305-8
  • Huang, S., Nyman, T. J., Jern, P., & Santtila, P. (2023). Actual and Desired Masturbation Frequency, Sexual Distress, and Their Correlates. Archives of sexual behavior. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-023-02641-3

A self-directed video course by Angus Munro, a clinical psychologist registered in Australia. Thirty-two video lessons, a one-page summary for each, and a plan you build for yourself.

Angus Munro wrote this page and sells the Porn Addiction Solution course. This page is general education; it can’t tell you what’s right for your situation.

Angus Munro

Clinical Psychologist, Sydney, Australia

Angus Munro is a clinical psychologist registered with AHPRA in Australia. He wrote the Porn Addiction Solution course.

Full profile and credentials